Bennett says she gets "a little freaked out" when planes rumble over at low altitudes but watching the gravity-defying planes is a family tradition. Both sustained fire and impact related damage. All those facts will enter the record as Federal Aviation Administration investigators Monday continued sifting through the wreckage of a Hillsboro neighborhood where the vintage British jet fighter struck with a full load of fuel. As a spectator, "you make an assumption that they know they're doing things right," Cheadle said of air show officials. "Accidents at air shows seem to have very little bearing on the public's willingness to come out. The company employs 17,000 people in and around Hillsboro, and has two major centers nearby: its Jones Farm facility, primarily an administrative site, and the Ronler Acres campus. "He loved flying.". And both are in less densely populated areas than Hillsboro. The witness reported that the airplane appeared to "wallow" nose high before it descended beyond his vantage point behind a tree line. "I relive it every day," added Halvorsen. The 73-year-old pilot died in the accident, one house was destroyed and three others were damaged. The couple has run off a flock of circling lawyers who have offered to sue on their behalf. From The Oregonian of Thursday, Aug. 9, 2007Safety in the air The crash killed the pilot and damaged two homes next to hers. Every year, Robert E. Guilford flew a former British Royal Air Force mechanic from England to California to perform a check on his 47-year-old Hawker-Siddeley Hunter MK-58. "We keep finding scraps of things and setting them aside for Donna," Wendy says. Cirrus SR20 G3, N99EC: Fatal accident occurred January 24, 2023 near Indianapolis Executive Airport (KTYQ), Indiana, Pilatus PC-12/47, Roadside Ventures LLC, N950KA: Fatal accident occurred June 07, 2012 in Lake Wales, Florida, Pilatus PC-12/47E, N79NX: Fatal accident occurred February 13, 2022 in Beaufort, Carteret County, North Carolina, Flight Control System Malfunction/Failure: Cessna 525A CitationJet CJ2+, N525EG; fatal accident occurred November 30, 2018 in Memphis, Clark County, Indiana, Cessna 208B Grand Caravan, N928JP: Fatal accident occurred April 13, 2022 near Burley Municipal Airport (KBYI), Cassia County, Idaho, Collision with Terrain (non-CFIT): Cessna 172M Skyhawk, N9049H; accident occurred September 11, 2022 in Fort Collins, Larimer County, Colorado, Cirrus SR20 G6, N700YZ: Fatal accident occurred November 05, 2022 at Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport (KMYF), San Diego, California, Embraer ERJ-175, N264NN: Fatal accident occurred December 31, 2022 at Montgomery Regional Airport (KMGM), Alabama, Embraer EMB-505 Phenom 300, N555NR: Fatal accident occurred January 02, 2023 at Provo Municipal Airport (KPVU), Utah County, Utah, Cessna 550 Citation II, N409ST: Accident occurred September 27, 2022 at Waco-McGregor Executive Airport (KPWG), Texas, Czech Sportcruiser, N823MM: Accident occurred March 24, 2022 near Lanark, New Mexico, Cirrus SR22 GTS, N24LA: Fatal accident occurred May 06, 2022 in the Atlantic Ocean near Tybee Island, Georgia, Cessna 208 Caravan, N333LD: May 10, 2022 at Palm Beach International Airport (KPBI), Palm Beach County, Florida, Cessna 152, N49931 and Cessna 340A, N740WJ: Fatal accident occurred August 18, 2022 near Watsonville Municipal Airport (KWVI), Santa Cruz County, California, CSA PiperSport, N126WK: Fatal accident occurred September 08, 2022 at Santa Monica Airport (KSMO), Los Angeles County, California, Beechcraft V35B Bonanza, N112TW: Fatal accident occurred July 16, 2021 near Angwin Airport-Parrett Field (2O3), Napa County, California, Robinson R44 Cadet, N514CD: Fatal accident occurred March 25, 2022 in Rowlett, Dallas County, Texas, CASA C-212-200 Aviocar, N497CA: Fatal accident occurred July 29, 2022 at Raleigh-Durham International Airport (KRDU), Morrisville, Wake County, North Carolina, Loss of Control in Flight: Cessna 525C Citation CJ4, N614SB, fatal accident occurred December 29, 2016 near Cleveland Burke Lakefront Airport (KBKL), Cleveland, Ohio, Seawind 3000, N8UU: July 03, 2021, July 02, 2021, June 27, 2021 and June 26, 2021, Loss of Control in Flight: Cirrus SR20, N4252G, fatal accident occurred June 09, 2016 near Hobby Airport (KHOU), Houston, Texas, Bombardier CL-600-2B16 Challenger 605, N605TR: Fatal accident occurred July 26, 2021 near Truckee Tahoe Airport (KTRK), Nevada County, California, Loss of Control in Flight: Cirrus SR22, N670SR; fatal accident occurred May 31, 2018 at Midland International Air and Space Port Airport (KMAF), Midland County, Texas, Medical Event: Cessna Citation 560, N3RB / N561EJ; fatal accident occurred January 09, 2021 in Warm Springs, Oregon, Loss of Control in Flight: SIAI Marchetti SM.1019B, N28U; fatal accident occurred July 24, 2021 at Lewiston-Nez Perce County Regional Airport (KLWS), Idaho. "The problem is that if we decide to have the house leveled, we could end up having to pay the difference out of our pocket. A 1958 graduate of Harvard Law School, Guilford was an air disaster attorney at Baum Hedlund. "It's creepy," said Wellman's son, Sean. The July 16 crash killed the jet's owner and pilot, Robert E. Guilford, 73, of Los Angeles and damaged four houses. The airframe total time at inspection was 2,907 hours. "Like the clothes I'm wearing aren't my own," Reynolds, 49, chimed in, looking down at her hand-me-down shorts. Josh Boer of Beaverton was selling raffle tickets when the plane "kind of floated down," striking the top of the two-story house in front of him. . ", From The Oregonian of Wednesday, July 19, 2006 Jerry F. Boone column: Area airport, not air show, the real worry. Thousands of spectators at the annual air show saw the plane take off and move at a slower-than-expected rate. "People would come up to me and say, 'Your dad's plane is so cool because it whistles.' From The Oregonian of Monday, July 24, 2006 Jerry F. Boone column: Living with fallout from the fireball. A second witness, also located near midfield, reported that the takeoff was "consistent" with what you would expect from a vintage jet. All that was recovered from the debris was a tattered piece of a stuffed dog with a button eye. Steve Guilford said his father was one of the few people authorized by the Federal Aviation Administration to certify pilots in transonic jets, similar to the one that crashed Sunday, and other high-performance combat airplanes. "At this point, it's premature to predict anything," spokesman Steve Callaway said. Knowing there was a field close by tells me he stayed with it until it was too late.". As another man grabbed a hose, Bryson attacked the front door. Air show organizers Monday said the event's future is unclear. "I've got my favorite trowel," she says. Behind her property, only a shell was left of Darren and Leslie Dilley's house. Guilford was a founding member of the Warbirds of America, plane enthusiasts who restore, fly and display former military aircraft, mainly at air shows. Published: Jul. The craft exploded into a fireball that spread to three more houses in the neighborhood about one mile east of the Hillsboro Airport, near the Orenco Station area. Numerous witnesses reported similar observations. Guilford said his father - a Los Angeles aviation lawyer and accomplished pilot - hired an expert on Hawker Hunter maintenance from England each year and used a Van Nuys, Calif., mechanic for periodic maintenance. "When you saw the smoke, you know that the worst possible thing had happened.". FAA inspectors reported that the airplane impacted terrain in a residential neighborhood near the departure airport. Since then, no spectator has been killed at an air show in North America, he said. But not every mishap is insignificant. Intense fire, flames.". A vintage British fighter jet crashed into a densely populated neighborhood near an airport during an air show Sunday afternoon, exploding, destroying a home and killing the pilot. Representatives from the NTSB, FAA and Rolls-Royce (Bristol, United Kingdom) examined the wreckage at a hangar facility in Independence, Oregon, on August 24-25, 2006. When the plane hit the house, it just shattered everything like a slingshot, Calkins said. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. I do this all the time, all around Washington County, he said. New sheathing was on rebuilt walls, new windows were in place and a stack of siding sat in the side yard, awaiting installation. As people were packing to go, announcers said over the public-address system that their thoughts and prayers were with Robert Guilford and his family. This year about 58,000 people attended the two-day show. "It's hard to top a plane landing on your house.". Other residents disagreed. It's very unlikely that it will happen again," said Bennett, adding that if she had been home the afternoon of the crash she might not be as supportive. From The Oregonian of Wednesday, July 19, 2006 Two growth patterns, one worry "We know it's going to take a while for things to get right," he says. 3, 2022 at 9:27 AM PDT. "The insurance company has already been out. For entertainment purposes, our lives are at stake.". GitHub export from English Wikipedia. To date, they've suffered no emotional effects from the near miss. Carl Calkins creates pieces out of recovered plane parts. By Holly Danks. Numerous witnesses reported similar observations. Steve Guilford said he was grateful that no one on the ground was injured or killed. What she feels the worst about losing in her house is the science-fiction book that her father had recorded on tape and she and her sister never got around to transcribing. As the silence weighed on the crowd, announcers restarted the music and then abruptly ended the show. The inspectors were in attendance at the air show, and arrived at the accident site immediately after the accident. . The jet crashed into a house, killing the. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. They talk about being nonprofit and giving money to charity --well, there are two children right here needing it the most and they are not offering anything to them. From the curb along Northeast Harvest Street, Steve and Wendy Applegarth's house looks like a typical well-kept, carefully landscaped and beautifully maintained Hillsboro home. The Federal Aviation Administration is still investigating the July 16, 2006, crash. But last fall, organizers decided to continue it after months of community forums moderated by leaders of the air show, the city and the Port of Portland, which runs the airport. On Sunday, Robert E. Guilford, a 73-year-old pilot, died after his vintage fighter jet struck a neighborhood a mile east of the airport while leaving the show. By Sarah Friesen, The Oregonian If you purchase a product or register for an. Among those crashes: In July, a stunt pilot who had performed in Hillsboro in 2001 died when his biplane slammed into the runway during a show in Dayton, Ohio. He said actor Tom Cruise saw his father's P-51 hangar at Van Nuys Airport and told airport officials he would pay double to lease it. Near the end of the air show, as Guilford lifted off from Portland-Hillsboro Airport (HIO) to return home to Los Angeles, his 1950s warbird lost power. HILLSBORO, Ore. (KOIN) On July 16, 2006, a 1951 Hawker Hunter Jet crashed during the Oregon International Air show at the Hillsboro Airport. Jet treats!' . It was blasted and burned away shortly after 4 p.m. July 16 when a vintage jet fighter leaving the Oregon International Airshow at nearby Hillsboro Airport apparently lost power and crashed into the unoccupied house. Reynolds designed her house 20 years ago and her father, Bill, who died in November 2004, did the siding and finish work. It brings me right back to that day. Robert E. Guilford's vintage Hawker-Siddeley Hunter MK-58 struck a neighborhood a mile east of the airport. "There may be some ill will or difficult feelings. Along with the FAA, the organization requires aerobatic pilots to meet safety rules, including performing in a "sterile box" that contains no other airplanes or people, only open land or empty houses. Both teams have contacted the air show about possibly performing, Willey said. Fire. "It's been a long year. He sprayed the hose while I yelled to see if anyone was inside. ", "But the new house won't include woodwork my father helped finish.". "You can buy new things to replace old things," she says. On Wednesday, Donna Reynolds talks about the things she lost that money can't replace. "And the neighbors have been just great," he says. A British-made Hawker Hunter fighter plane crashed at about 4:30 p.m., toward the end of the two-day Hillsboro International Air Show. Inspectors from the FAA's Portland, Oregon, Flight Standards District Office (FSDO), conducted the onsite investigation. Guilford said he learned of Sunday's crash from his father's mechanic at Van Nuys Airport. It used to be filled with my Little Golden Books. Despite Intel's concerns, Standard TV & Appliance - the air show's primary sponsor for three years - will continue with the event, said Mark Rossolo, a company marketing representative. We'll never know if it was good fortune or the skills of a very good pilot that caused the jet to miss a more populated area. People were not allowed to touch Guilford's plane, unlike other aircraft. In an e-mail, Intel spokesman Bill MacKenzie wrote Thursday: "Our position today remains the same. The plane, which had been on static display during the weekend air show, departed the airport to the north at 4:20 p.m. Bending deformation, opposite the direction of rotation, and thermal deformation was noted. He died when his Hawker Hunter Mk. It crashed shortly after takeoff Sunday afternoon on its return to California. In its studies of the airport's potential, port managers have been politely dismissive of the noise and safety concerns of the airport's neighbors. Hand written notes in the logbook indicated that the pilot's total flying experience in the accident airplane (make and model) was approximately 161 hours. The walls were standing, but flames and jet fuel spewed through the back windows and destroyed everything inside. Event coordinators reported that the pilot planned to make 3 non-aerobatic low passes over the runway after departing from runway 30. Once the yard was restored, airshow volunteers helped build a fence and begin the process of bringing it back to its pre-crash condition. Details on hundreds of great aviation events across the US and Canada, easily accessible from your desktop, laptop, tablet or phone. July's wreck was the first in the show's 19-year history. "I don't like the sound and if it seems a lot lower.". "We feel very sorry for the pilot who died but grateful no one else was injured.". They weren't nearly as concerned for their house as they were for their neighbors, who are up in years and could have been in danger from the fuel-fed fire. No one on the ground was hurt. more than it should have required. There is some logic in that. Several eyewitnesses, both in attendance at the show, and others located in the residential community where the airplane crashed, submitted written statements to the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) detailing their observations during the accident sequence. Among the changes, air show organizers will implement more guidelines for participants. Others contended the crash was an indication of the dangers the community would face if the show goes on. He refinished it. And it isn't expected to slow any time soon. Next door to Reynolds, a wall of Steve and Wendy Applegarth's home had to be rebuilt. That's understandable," Callaway said. "There are constant reminders.". Bob Cheadle, who lives one home from where the plane destroyed a house, says he has no reservations about the event. Three people were taken to the hospital after a serious crash involving two vehicles on Jan. 2, 2023. Somehow he got out alive. "She doesn't have much else. This one honors the dog who safety got out of the house. Hillsboro Airport is the largest of three general aviation airports operated by the Port of Portland. Show organizers on Thursday announced plans to return in 2007 with stronger safety requirements. The garden tool was among the few things salvageable after a vintage jet leaving the Oregon International Airshow on July 16 crashed into her Hillsboro home and turned it into an inferno. Steve says they just want to get back to normal. No one offers jet treats to Reynolds, who describes her recent life as traveling the line of a sine curve: a roller coaster of ups and downs. "He was not a fly-by-night guy," he said. The commercial pilot, the registered owner and operator of the airplane, was fatally injured. Bruce Wilson, newly elected president of the International Council of Airshows, argues that the crash of a vintage jet fighter leaving the airport was not an air show accident. From initial market research to long-term aircraft management, we are your partner in the air and on the ground. The 24th annual Oregon International Airshow takes flight in this video produced by TVCTV that gives viewers a behind-the-scenes look at the coordination and. . The aft section of the compressor assembly, stages 8 through 15 were intact. Compressor blade tip erosion was noted to disks 8 through 13. A corresponding logbook entry showed that the engine total time was 1,359 hours. Its mainly his son promoting the dad was a hero story (for plunging into three homes instead of a shopping mall? And he couldnt get the Corsair back.And of course his career was in aviation liability, which has skyrocketed prices for all pilots. From The Oregonian of Friday, July 21, 2006 Residents divided over air show safety concerns In August, he expects to have family over to watch the show from his backyard. Before workers hauled away contaminated soil, Reynolds searched the rubble but found only scraps of clothing and pieces of dishes. Add to Calendar: Connect with us! It looped back before striking the ground just out of view of thousands of people attending the annual show. We aren't sure we want to do that.". I always work upstairs. Guilford's son, Steve, said Monday he thinks the plane's engine wasn't getting enough fuel. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed for the local flight conducted under the provisions of 14 CFR Part 91. The accident occurred during the Oregon International Air Show. Two people in the vehicle that was hit were pronounced dead at the scene. "But the Katrina population is no longer. But you can learn from it while planning for the future. One home was destroyed and two others were damaged by the post crash fire. Stunned by the dark turn of events, commentators turned off the music. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Kenitzer said the National Transportation Safety Board turned over the investigation to the FAA because the Hawker Hunter was licensed as an "experimental exhibition" and the pilot was the only one killed. Gates open at 12pm and close at 5pm; Flying starts APPROXIMATELY at 1pm; Saturday & Sunday. "I can go to a bookstore and buy a replacement copy. They aren't your old things and they aren't your favorite things. . . Donna Reynolds, 48, lost her two-story home and all of her belongings when the plane crashed. I've used it ever since I was a little girl. Show organizers will announce the performance lineup after the well-known military jet teams - the U.S. Navy Blue Angels or the U.S. Air Force Thunderbirds - announce their schedules Dec. 6. The first witness reported that the airplane was "lower and slower" than what he would have expected. Investigators with the Federal Aviation Administration, with assistance from Lt. Steve Klaus (center) of the Hillsboro Fire Department, look through the wreckage Monday (June 17, 2006) of a plane that crashed into a Hillsboro house Sunday during the Oregon International Airshow. Terry Betts was in his backyard when he saw the plane slipping low over the housetops. ", From The Oregonian of Tuesday, July 18, 2006 Explanations few for homeowner ", From The Oregonian of Thursday, Aug. 9, 2007Residents at crash site dread show's return Email: | Phone: 503-629-0706. Aurora Composite Squadron Address. But some people who live in the neighborhood east of the Hillsboro Airport, where a jet crashed when leaving last year's air show, don't like living with the odds -- or the memories. During the show's continuous 19-year run, the area around the Hillsboro Airport has undergone explosive development, adding sprawling neighborhoods and high-tech employers, while the city's population grew from 31,000 to 82,000. "I went shopping a few weeks ago and found a shirt on the rack exactly like one that had been burned up. In addition to the internal fuel tanks (approximate capacity of 392 gallons), the airplane was equipped with four (two inboard and two outboard) external drop tanks. From The Oregonian of Monday, July 17, 2006 -- 'It just fell out of the sky': A jet leaving the Oregon International Airshow crashes into a Hillsboro house and explodes into a fireball, killing the pilot and horrifying people on the ground, From The Oregonian of Monday, July 17, 2006 -- Pilot loved powerful combat planes: Robert Guilford's son says his father likely chose not to eject to protect people below, From The Oregonian of Tuesday, July 18, 2006 -- Explanations few for homeowner: Donna Reynolds says she can't say why she was spared when her home was struck by a vintage jet fighter, From The Oregonian of Tuesday, July 18, 2006 -- Tragedy clouds air show's future: Sunday's vintage jet crash has Intel and other neighbors questioning whether the annual event should return, From The Oregonian of Wednesday, July 19, 2006 -- Jerry F. Boone column: Area airport, not air show, the real worry, From The Oregonian of Wednesday, July 19, 2006 -- Two growth patterns, one worry: Safety Hillsboro expects to add 40,00 residents by 2025 -- plus 100,000 more annual flights from its airport, From The Oregonian of Friday, July 21, 2006 -- Residents divided over air show safety concerns: Spurred by a weekend crash, the public jams an auditorium to discuss airport issues, From The Oregonian of Monday, July 24, 2006 -- Jerry F. Boone column: Living with fallout from the fireball, From The Oregonian of Monday, Sept. 25, 2006 -- Jerry F. Boone column: Homes slowly rise from ashes of the air crash. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. "I don't think it's an excuse to say, 'We haven't had this happen in 19 years,' " Ahrendt said. ", From The Oregonian of Sunday, Nov. 19, 2006News Update: New home coming to crash site They crinkle like dry cereal as the autumn breeze blows through scorched branches. They thanked people for coming and said rescuers were taking care of the problem. Guilford was in Hillsboro for show and tell. Neighbor Carl Calkins, a self-professed treasure hunter, has gathered some elements of the jet and created memorabilia. He also reported that the gear appeared to be in the "extended" position. Robert E. Guilford flies his Hawker-Siddeley Hunter MK-58 in March 2004. ", From The Oregonian of Monday, Sept. 25, 2006 Jerry F. Boone column: Homes slowly rise from ashes of the air crash. She and her dog Lacey, a Labrador-Rottweiler-shepherd mix that somehow escaped the crash, have been living in a rental. From The Oregonian of Wednesday, Sept. 27, 2006 -- Jerry F. Boone column: How do you put a price on memories? That's also what organizers of the 19-year-old Hillsboro event would have us believe. The thrill lessened as the Oregon International Airshow, which staged its 19th annual program during the weekend, became more routine. On their drive back along the Sunset Highway about 4:30 p.m., they could see a huge column of black smoke rising near the Hillsboro Airport. 3- vehicle crash closes Hillsboro Hwy, 3 injured (Washington County Sheriff's Office) By FOX 12 Staff Published: Feb. 4, 2023 at 5:41 PM PST HILLSBORO Ore. (KPTV) - Three people were injured. "Everyone seems to really want to do what's right. Investigators will find a scene devastated by a fire fed by fast-burning jet fuel. A 1951 Hunter Hawker fighter had been on static display. That degree of separation makes the airplane crash even more unsettling. With added residents and businesses, the Hillsboro Airport -- once the bastion of private pilots and small aircraft -- became busier. There was a huge fireball. No one was in the house when the plane struck. "It has become a signature event for the Hillsboro community.". "I saw a part of the fuselage and engine was just lying on the back patio. Apparently the pilot was attempting a loop and did not pull out in time. The wreckage debris field, as measured by FAA personnel, was approximately 150 feet in length and 65 feet wide. Air show officials received permission from city leaders and the Port of Portland last week to hold the 2007 event Aug. 11-12. "We would like to be part of the discussion about where the community goes from here in terms of the air show," MacKenzie said. Betts said it looked as though the pilot might be trying to get the struggling plane beyond the houses to a field. "I don't know why I was spared and the pilot wasn't," she said. Two other houses damaged in the crash have been repaired, A third, directly behind Reynolds' lot on Northeast Stile Drive, had to be torn down because jet fuel spewed through the interior. The house belonged to Donna Reynolds and although she has since rebuilt her home on the same property, she still occasionally finds scarps of the jet in . The company, which employs 17,000 workers in Washington County, has three campuses near the airport and is one of its primary users. Just before 12 p.m. on Friday, police identified the two people who died as 19-year-old Adriana Shelton, from Sheridan . The airplane was a static display at the air show and, with the exception of the accident flight, the airplane did not fly during the event. But her dog was. The flames ate into the attic and interior rooms, and the heat cracked windows and singed curtains. Officials from the Federal Aviation Administration were at the site Sunday night, and National Transportation Safety Board investigators were expected to arrive at the site today. By Esmeralda Bermudez. Across the back fence, life is returning to normal for Diana Halvorsen and her family. The Halvorsens, Reynolds and the Dilleys decided not to move out of the neighborhood, saying they didn't want to leave friends who have been so supportive through the ordeal. Reynolds and the Dilleys were not home. Visitors can enjoy aerobatic stunts, ground aircrafts displays and plenty of entertainment. Amazing dichotomy online about this pilot and this incident. One witness, who was located near midfield, reported that the pilot's takeoff was "conservative" and the engine sounded "normal." Carl Calkins creates pieces out of recovered plane parts. About 60 percent of it is beyond salvaging, he says. "I wanted to crawl out of my skin, but there wasn't anywhere to go.". During the two-hour meeting, representatives from the Port, the Oregon International Airshow and the Federal Aviation Administration took turns reviewing safety standards for the show and details of the investigation. "The contamination wasn't nearly as bad as first thought," she says. "As the airport operator, the main requirement we're involved in is focused on airport property," said Port spokesman Steve Johnson. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. . The annual Hillsboro airshow here in Oregon ended 30-minutes early today in a tragic crash. The soil contaminated with unburned jet fuel has been dug out and removed. "People come by to look at it, but it doesn't seem like anyone is doing anything yet.". Oregon International Air Show returns to Hillsboro May 20-22 Weather Alert 1 MORE ALERTS There are 18 areas under alert. The only thing left standing was her garage, and her two vehicles were spared. "He was a very experienced pilot, with over 4,000 hours in all types of combat aircraft," he said. "I looked out the window just in time to see it hit the house next-door.". "But you're dealing with 50-year-old machines. Sunday's vintage jet crash has Intel and other neighbors questioning whether the annual event should return